Aranmanai 4

Gopinath Rajendran of The Hindu wrote, "Sundar C makes a much-needed comeback with the most intriguing addition to the ‘Aranmanai’ franchise, thanks to an engaging plot headlined by Tamannaah".

Akshay Kumar from The New Indian Express gave the film 3 out of 5 stars, stating, "An in-form Sundar C finds the sweet spot between humour and horror".

Janani K. of India Today rated the film 2/5 stars, commenting, "Negatives overpower positives in Sundar C’s horror-comedy, which is full of redundant ideas and little laughs." She points out that the film's few strengths are overshadowed by redundant ideas and a lack of genuine laughs, resulting in a tedious experience for the viewer.

Latha Srinivasan of Hindustan Times said the film is "timepass and if you go in with no expectations, you will not come out raving about the film but you won’t come out bitterly disappointed either".

Suganth of The Times of India gave the film 2.5/5 stars and mentioned, "A predictable, forgettable, and mildly entertaining rehash", while noting the film's adherence to a proven formula.

Manigandan KR of Times Now gave the film 3.5/5 stars and stated, "Sundar C’s horror-comedy makes you both shudder and laugh", praising the film for delivering a mix of thrills and entertainment.

News18 wrote, "Sundar C’s gripping storyline makes it a must-watch", and praised him for delivering a blend of horror and comedy, featuring engaging performances by the leads.

The Indian Express gave a dismal 1/5 stars, stating, "A new day and a new 'Aranmanai' film with the same old problems; another lackluster entry that fails to provide either thrills or chills." The review expresses disappointment in the film's writing and accuses it of laziness, suggesting that the franchise has become too reliant on a formulaic approach.