Avad Mohammad of OTTPlay gave a rating of 2 out of 5 and stated that "The film's twists may have sounded good on paper, but their on-screen execution is underwhelming", while also mentioning that narration, editing, and screenplay are dull and uninspiring.
Avad Mohammad of OTTplay gave 3/5 stars and wrote,"On the whole, Manamey is a feel-good romantic family drama that has some endearing moments in both halves".
Avad Mohammad of OTTPlay wrote that "Shivam Bhaje has a very interesting point but starts on a slow note and takes forever to enter the main conflict point".